On April 19, 1988, two armed assailants entered the Suncrest, Washington, home of Doyle Wheeler, a former officer from the San Diego Police Department. All three women struggled with drug addiction and drugs would be found in their systems upon autopsy. On the evening of March 28, Gainor left the police station after receiving a phone call. It was called Operation Tarnished Badge and it found that people in the sheriffs office were involved in kidnapping, drug trafficking, and money laundering. April 4, 1979 Loureen Hassell, unknown age, unknown cause of death. The victim's husband was out of town and was not considered a suspect. April 21, 2000 Richard Keevil, 20, shotgun. Feb. 4, 1992 Clarence Thomas, 31, shot. When someone shares a story about a close encounter with aliens, its easy write them off as a crazy person. NC faces crisis of murdered and missing Native American women | Raleigh Valdosta, Ga., was found beaten to death in a vacant lot off Person Street near North Carolina Category page. She was too decomposed. When the two officers arrived at the mosque, they ran up the stairs and were confronted by a dozen men, who forced them back down. Keep in touch. Nov. 7, 1994 Lawrence Tomlinson, 50, blunt force. Wiley also never accessed any of the money in his bank account or police pension fund, and there is no paper trail for him. A case is defined as cleared when an arrest is made or there is an exception, such as a suspected killer being dead or incarcerated for another crime. We have given inadequate resources to properly fund local police departments. This is one of the most frustrating to understand. Shelby Williams, 32, of 620 Campbell I think you were able to truly portray your interest in the topic through your blog and were cognizant of the sentiments attached to such like stories. March 15, 1998 Derren Patterson, 29, shot. Most people consider this case closed, so we may never know the truth. Nov. 19, 1999 Albert Griffin, unknown age, shot. was beaten he drowned in College Lake on Sept. 9, 1991. Your chances of being raped, assaulted, or killed were 1 in 55 based on data from 2016. Upon autopsy for all three women it was determined that their causes of death were undetermined. None are currently classified as homicides. March 2, 1981 Janice Murphy Perry, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Examining the world of solved and unsolved cases. For comparison, Pinehurst (1.5 hours away) the crime rate is 69.7% lower than the national rate and 72.5% lower than the North Carolina crime rate. Sheila spends over 60 hours a week working to get her groups name out there as well as raise awareness of problems in the community, and making sure that other victims families know they arent alone in this. (2012) All rights reserved. Theresa Blackwell, 27, of Fayetteville was found beaten and possibly Sheila and her daughter (Megans sister) Shirlyn have been making lists of the missing and murdered women in Lumberton. $5,000REWARD for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person(s) responsible for the murder of Kathi Goff Kennedy, 35-year-oldmother of two small children in Kernersville. One of those people was Megan Oxendine. Following is the list of unsolved murders under the jurisdiction of the Gainor was also clutching a leather bag containing several items, including some custom-made silk shirts. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. If your child will play baseball or softball this spring, youll need to stock up on appropriate clothing and equipment. Curiously, Wileys friend never received this letter, and no copy of it was found. The fact that weve done so many interviews. Four years. Megan moved to Lumberton and began her struggle with drugs which got worse when she started using heroin in 2016. The following morning, three men were caught trying to sneak off the island on a ferry. (Source: Fayetteville Observer). Mayford was entrusted with a set of keys that allowed him to check inside the businesses while they were closed at night. When more cops arrived at the scene, a fight broke out in the reception area, and most of the officers were locked outside. Frederick Robert Klenner Jr. Frederick Rober Klenner Jr. was considered a mass murderer who killed several victims between 1984 and 1985. On the evening of October 22, Jones told the dispatcher that she was doing a patrol near the islands lighthouse and uttered the phrase: Show me out with three. Jones could then be heard urging someone to put their gun down before a high-pitched squeal cut off the radio transmission. I aint gonna stop fighting. He said he was very close with his father and recalled a story Birt had told him during a prison visit, when he admitted to killing three people in the North Carolina mountains during a heavy snowstorm, remembering that they almost got caught.. According to Schirmer, the unidentified lights immediately took off into the sky and vanished. North Carolina: The Edgecombe County Serial Killer. This aint my job. Asha Degree. In the words of Megan Oxendines sister, Khelia Oxendine, Its a bad area. Megans youngest sister, Taylor Oxendine reiterated with, Theres all kinds of violent mess there. Lumberton is the 22nd most populated county out of North Carolinas 100 counties, but it has the greatest prevalence of homicides of the state and holds the grim distinction of one of the nations most violent rural communities. In the town, youths are 2 times more likely than other parts of the state to die before they reach age 18. the Murderpedia project stay alive. Source: Fayetteville Police Department. While OMaras family successfully lobbied to have the medical examiner change his cause of death from suicide to undetermined, authorities continue to maintain that OMara killed himself. Category:North Carolina | Unsolved Mysteries Wiki | Fandom I aint gonna stop fighting. Shes just quiet. April 6, 1987 Karem Khalid Abdul, 25, unknown cause of death. However, Ralstin passed away several months later at the age of 90, so the murder of George Coniff officially remains unsolved. GIBSON, Jose Luis & Alonso Even though he was 66 years old, August Mayford was employed by the Alton, Illinois, police department as a special patrolman and merchants watchman for the downtown business district. Cold Case Homicides | Greensboro, NC Aug. 1, 1987 Brenda Melvin, 26, strangulation. Jan. 17, 1979 Roger McLaren, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Nov. 3, 2001 Antwone Jones, 23, shot. Cynthia has black/brown hair and brown eyes and is part of the Lumbee tribe. March 3, 1999 Baby Michael, newborn, thrown from a car. I know that they sacrificed many days and weekends in order to work on solving this case since 1972, she said, noting that some officers continued to work on the case even in retirement. A warrant was issued for Deanos arrest, but he could not be located. The fact that we have consulted with so many different departments. Since OMara spent a portion of his career taking down the Illinois mafia, one theory was that his death was a revenge killing. He had been shot in the back eight times and was beaten so severely that his jaw was broken. She was too decomposed. FBI special agent John Strong said, We owe it to each of these women, we owe it to their families, we owe it to this community to put together the pieces of the puzzle and to provide the answers of what happened in it.. Oct. 19, 1986. June 25, 1989 James Holley, 20, clubbed to death. A witness saw Gainor talking to some men inside a blue sedan a half hour later. They were up to 377 at the most recent count documented in news articles. But, I will say I do believe that we have promising evidence. Gillian, this was so interesting! She had attended rehab in March to combat her crack addiction. George Schirmer also had a splitting headache and an unexplained red welt on his neck. She actually grew up in Virginia and moved to North Carolina in 2016 to go to school. Holland, a Campbell College drama student, was . Exactly what happened next is unknown to this day. To this day, there have been no leads and no suspects, but there have been a number of other missing and murdered women in Lumberton whos disappearances and deaths continue to be unsolved. Even though it was raining, there was a large unexplained large dry spot in the middle of the wet road. Some of the murders may 1990. CrimeStoppers pays cash for information leading to arrests in felony cases and callers never have to identify themselves. Im so tired. Aug. 20, 1974 Denise King, unknown age, unknown cause of death. He had been beaten. Fugitive in rape case found in Illinois - Kait8.com To date, no one has been arrested for the tragic murder of this mother, Deborah Nunnery. We are putting a lot of effort into finding out who placed them they are. Jan. 7, 1981 Roy Warren, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Physical evidence from both the abduction site and the body recovery site was sent to the SBI Laboratory for processing. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Maybe the police grasped for straws when coming up with evidence to link Pittman to the crimes because they had no other suspects and wanted to resolve the matter in any way they could. There was not enough physical evidence to link him to the other murders, but they did stop after he was taken into custody, so it is very likely that he was indeed the Edgecombe County Serial Killer. I am also a big true crime junkie so I am eager to hear more of your opinions on these cases. While her father died when she was a child, she lived with her mother, Jevona Livingston, and her half-siblings, Chris and Becca. In 2021, only 51% of homicides were solved, according to FBI statistics analyzed by the Murder Accountability Project. Unsolved Missing and Murder Cases in North Carolina | Uncovered 1995. The body was over a guardrail, approximately 15 feet down an embankment, just east of the New Hope Church Road exit. If you have information about this case or any unsolved case in North Carolina, please contact the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation, (800) 334-3000. Aug. 23, 1998 William Poe, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Angelo Miles II, 16, of 1113 Turnpike March 11, 1979 Rooneycq Harris, unknown age, unknown cause of death Mrs. Kennedyand her family had lived in the apartment complex for only three weeks. discovered in his apartment on April 6, 1987. In 1985, Jacobs and his partner, Thomas Riggs, had pulled over an African-American man named Sagon Penn for a traffic violation, leading to an altercation in which Penn shot Riggs to death and wounded Jacobs. UNSOLVED HOMICIDE. As my previous posts have made clear, such a lifestyle is commonplace in victims of violent crime because it makes them both vulnerable to finding themselves in dangerous situations and less likely to be reported missing when things go horribly wrong. These murders are among NC's biggest unsolved mysteries. Despite this, he plead not guilty, but was convicted and sentenced to life in prison without parole for her death. The same amount of hours. The next day when she did not hear from her daughter, the victim's mother went to the Springbrook Apartment Complex. We are still putting forth the same amount of, effort. This Caldwell County North Carolina Most Wanted List posts the top 50-100 fugitive criminals on the run. There is a Governor's reward of $5,000 for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person or persons responsible. Feb. 9, 1984 William McKoy, unknown age, handgun. Brad Bishop; Richard Bare; Frederick Young; Rhonda Hinson; Judith Smith; Marshall Lee Brown; Debbie Wolfe; He had been beaten and shot in the head four times. I had to cremate my daughter. Hundreds of leads provided by the public have been investigated. home as she slept on Oct. 20, 1994. First was 41-year-old Cynthia Twister Jacobs. October 2, 2021. After Mayford went missing, his wallet and some of his clothing were found inside a local shoe store. The body was that of 32-year-old Christina Kristin Bennett. It was later determined that they were Mayfords backup keys. A lead in the case emerged in 2019 when Shane Birt, the son of Billy Sunday Birt, visited the White County Sheriffs Office in Georgia to participate in research for a book about notorious crimes in the state. $20,000 REWARD for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person(s) responsible for the murder of Brittany Lynn Locklear. Megan had prostitution charges that were pending in Robeson County and had a court date in July of 2017. He claimed to have acted as the getaway driver that fateful night and said the three other men entered the house. Medical Center after a man walked into his business on July 31, 1989, and shot Precision Collision Electric Shop on Goins Drive, died at Cape Fear Valley Whether this is labeled a homicide. June 27, 1989 Terrence Robinson, 31, unknown cause of death. The State Bureau of Investigation (SBI) Cold Case Investigation Team (CCIT) was founded in 2020. B Street on Oct. 28, 1985. Robin Warder is a budding Canadian screenwriter who has used his encyclopedic movie knowledge to publish numerous articles at Cracked.com. The BAU said that this suspect may have left the community after the murders and if they didnt leave they likely changed their behavior or MO. Nov. 17, 1977 James Shifflett, unknown age, unknown cause of death. The killings are listed according to the A North Carolina Bureau of Investigations (NCBI) special agent involved with the case said, We cant really discuss any specific evidence that we have in the case. Investigators interviewed two sources to corroborate evidence from the crime scene. Sept. 28, 1987 Joshua Peoples, unknown age, unknown cause of death. The second victim reported missing was Christine Boone, who was not found until over three years after her relatives filed the report in 2007. The same amount of resources and I think the fact that we have the reward out there. Nov. 16, 1995 Ledell McGougan, 38, shot. We simply lack the necessary resources to properly investigate major crimes.. I know I also speak for the entire Watauga County community when I say that we will never forget to keep the Durham family in our thoughts and prayers, he added. Rhonda Jones, Megan Oxendine, and Christina Bennett were 3 women dealing with their own demons when each of them were found dead. Gregory Lockamy, 34, of Branson Street died from smoke inhalation in a fire to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really Seven Infamous Bone-Chilling Unsolved Mysteries in NC - OnlyInYourState If you have information about this caseor any unsolved case in North Carolina, please contact the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation,(800) 334-3000. July 5, 1999 Maricia Rice, 30, handgun. Her family began to express concern for Jessicas well-being after she entered into a relationship with a, EARLY LIFE: Jamie Michelle Fraley was born on March 5, 1986 in Gaston County, North Carolina. a 501c3 tax exempt non-profit organization, founded in Wilmington, North Carolina, serving missing persons nationwide. The missing cattle were soon found in a field behind a locked gate, but there was no sign of any hoof prints. Triple murder solved 50 years after North Carolina family found slain Jan. 14, 1999 Tyrone Garrett, 19, blunt force. New Hampshire: The Connecticut River Valley Killer, Massachusetts: The New Bedford Highway Killer. Cynthia was 41-years-old in 2017 (making her about 44-45 now). April 20, 2002 Janet Norris, 39, asphyxiation (Suspect Isaac Micah McDonald) While one round had been discharged from OMaras gun, the fatal bullet which killed him was never found, and testing could not determine if OMara had fired his own weapon. The notoriety behind Godfreys story eventually forced him to resign from the police force, but he continues to maintain that the events actually happened. Blandenboro Fire Poltergeist, Bladenboro, 1932 Good Reads Mrs. Charles Williamson was just an ordinary housewife until one day her dress unexplainably caught fire. Oct. 27, 1983 Human remains, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Sept. 13, 1964 Terry and Alan Westerfield, unknown ages, un known cause of Will NN Williamsburg Airport survive long term? If you have information about this case, call the Sampson County Sheriff's Office (910) 592-4141. have been solved but only a few. $20,000 REWARD for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person (s) responsible for the murder of Brittany Lynn Locklear. found dead on Feb. 7, 1981, in a wooded area near his home. In the autopsy report for Christina Bennett it reads: The grey blanket is disposed of at the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner at the request of law enforcement.. News | fayobserver.com, Family of Woman Found Dead in Lumberton 4 Years Ago Takes Up Cause of all Missing and Murdered in the City | insideedition.com, Families of women whose bodies found 3 years ago plead for help | robesonian.com, FBI, police search for clues in deaths of 3 Lumberton women 4 years later; $40K reward offered | wbtw.com, Lumberton, North Carolina, Where 3 Women Mysteriously Died Last Year, Has Sordid History of Violence | insideedition.com, Pinehurst, NC Crime Report, 2021 | homesnacks.com, Most Dangerous Cities in NC | newsovserver.com, Jensen & Holes | The Murder Squad Podcast. A lot of strange events surrounded Godfreys encounter. Oct. 13, 1996 Gaylord Johnson, unknown age, shot. Washington CARAWAN, Gregory Cumberland County Sheriff's Office. April 5, 1984 Richard Pursel, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Additional murders will be added. 1997 Stella Bobbit, unknown age, shot. We are putting a lot of effort into finding out who placed them they are. She also created a group called Shatter the Silence that started as a Facebook group in 2018 and is now working on getting nonprofit status. The day after Joness death, a prominent local family was holding a wedding in the same area, and the authorities wanted the bloody crime scene cleaned up. COPYRIGHT: Many, if not most should be considered armed and dangerous. The most likely theory was that Mayford interrupted a burglary attempt at the store and was subsequently abducted and murdered. On June 3, 2017, Megans nude body was found under branches and roof shingles in the unmowed brush of another abandoned house at 608 E. 8th Street, just about 500 feet from where the bodies of Christina and Rhonda were found. The killings are listed according to the date of the murder, the name of victim(s), their age and how they were killed. This report was never properly followed up, but after reopening the investigation and interviewing some witnesses, Bamonte came to believe that this allegation might be true. Dating back to the 1500's, here are seven of the most infamous unsolved mysteries in North Carolina. Sept. 15, 1985 Angelo Miles, 16, handgun. Wiley even claimed he had been working on a novel, but investigators could never find any manuscript for it. Then on April 18, 2017, her body was found dead in the TV cabinet of an abandoned home at 505 Peachtree Street. There were missteps in the working of these cases. The women were not the first murders like this in Lumberton and they wouldnt be the last to follow similar patterns. When she was last seen that Sunday, she was wearing a long-sleeve brown shirt and blue jeans. The officers showed up at the little blue house with boarded up windows and upon entering the house found that there were still pieces of furniture left behind. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. Darlene Tilley's unsolved murder is currently the oldest unsolved murder in North Carolina history. 40-year-old unsolved triple murder still haunts law enforcement At the Greenville Police Department, we recognize that murders, especially unsolved, can be extremely difficult for family, friends and the community. Aug. 10, 1996 Ruby Carter, 81, stabbed. at 2503 Camden Road near the Owen Drive intersection, was beaten and strangled Your email address will not be published. We sincerely thank you for your commitment. The body was over a guardrail, approximately 15 feet down an embankment, just east of the New Hope Church Road exit. Deborah would sometimes stay with her parents although she had her own residence in Quail Run Trailer Park in Roseboro. After being blinded by a bright flash, Godfrey experienced his own missing time episode. At one time she wanted to be a veterinarian. Police officers make their living fighting crime and solving mysteries, but what happens when the shoe is on the other foot? It remains one of Vermont's most enduring mysteries. Whodunnit? These murders are among NC's biggest unsolved mysteries. The Watauga County Sheriffs Office alerted the Durham family about the findings in November. Investigators performed an analysis on the typewriters ribbon and discovered that Wiley had typed a letter to a friend, in which he claimed that he was tired of his life and wanted to disappear. Megan Oxendines sister, Shirlyn Whitaker expressed the frustration that the families felt finding this out, Evidence sat on that shelf for 21 months. When Rhonda Jones body was found, Megan was interviewed by the local news. On the evening of May 30, OMara told his family that he was going out to buy some frozen yogurt. Once they moved, Christina got involved in drugs. June 29, 2002 Jennifer Wright, 32, strangled. On the morning of Wednesday, January 7, 1998 as she stood waiting for the school bus to pick her up, 5-year-old Brittany Locklear was abducted from outside her home on Grainey Road in Hoke County. Required fields are marked *. He was known for rigidly enforcing Prohibition laws and being one of the few honest cops in the area. They proceeded to bring Schirmer aboard their spacecraft to communicate with him, claiming that they had been watching over the human race and were experimenting on them as part of a breeding analysis program. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Sheila believes wholeheartedly that these 3 murders are connected. Last updated: January 12, 2011. April 12, 1984 Daniel Callahan, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Davis said they almost got caught in the bad snowstorm. The country is seeing a continued decline in cleared cases compared to previous decades when the rate was closer to 70%. Faith Hedgepeth Murder. 10 Bizarre Unsolved Mysteries Involving Police Officers She was discovered on May 30th, 2005, and an autopsy revealed that her cause of death was blunt force trauma to the head and that she also suffered multiple stab wounds. Im not giving up. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. If you have information about this case or any unsolved case in North Carolina, please contact the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation, (800) 334-3000. Making Lumberton the most diverse city in North Carolina. Terrace was strangled to death. February 14, 2000. Faith Hedgepeth Murder. Rising crime rates have become a central focus in major metropolitan areas including New York City, Philadelphia and Chicago. Missing. Nov. 21, 1976 Jimmy Byrd, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Nearly half of US murders going unsolved, data show Uncovered: Unsolved North Carolina Murders But what if a respected police officer makes the claim? However, the police dont think that Abbys disappearance is linked to Christina, Rhonda, and Megan because, she wasnt out on the streets.. The most intriguing clue, however, came from Wileys office typewriter. 1. Sept. 10, 1983 James Earl Ferguson, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Bryce Durham, 51, his wife, Virginia, 44, and their son, Bobby, 18, were found dead in their home duringa snowstorm Feb. 3, 1972, in a chilling attack that became locally known as the Durham Case.. Sept. 27, 1987 Rebecca Thompson, 19, handgun. They feel that this suspect may have told someone what they did and the confidante may have just brushed it off. need your help for this. 48 Eerie Unsolved Mysteries That Will Keep You Awake at Night - The Lineup deliberately started on Nov. 24, 1991. On Sunday,October 26, 1997 in the early morning hours, the body of Deborah Gail Nunnery was found on the roadwayof Underwood Road in the Snow Hill Community of Clinton. Sept. 28, 2002 Chas Sanchez, 25, shot. July 18, 1997 Robbie Jacobs, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Brooke Cain and Martha Quillin, The News & Observer (TNS) 0:05 0:57 For decades, felonious minds have been getting better at getting. Nov. 14, 1993 Nathan Turner, 14, shot. Jerome Johnson of 917 Davis St. was Because of a lack of proof, however, it still begs the question: Was Antwan Pittman really responsible for the deaths of all of these women? on May 3, 1986. Dec. 27, 1991 Steven Richie, 19, shot. Four years. NCSBI - Kathi Goff Kennedy On April 17th, 2017, Rhonda was supposed to have a court date to get visitation. In spite of an extensive investigation, the full truth behind the alleged attack on Doyle Wheeler was never uncovered. When investigators checked Wileys apartment, there were no signs of foul play. Around 6 PM, Abbys mom called the police to report Abby missing. Updated: Feb 28, 2023 / 09:41 PM EST. May 30, 1980 Carl Purcell March, unknown age, unknown cause of death. For decades, the Jeffrey MacDonald case was North Carolina's most famous crime, but the notoriety surrounding the mysterious death of Durham's Kathleen Peterson and the murder trial of her . Five months earlier, Godfrey had discovered the body of a man named Zygmunt Adamski in a Todmorden coal yard. He quickly returned to the police station and wrote in his logbook that he had seen a flying saucer. 1, 1987. Handcrafted with love by Georgia Lou Studios. The police officers listed here were victimized by mysterious events, some of which were possibly supernatural in nature. They picked up two women but soon cut them loose and drove off with their purses. death. Other women who were found dead before Christina, Rhonda, and Megan were never solved, and it was said that there was no evidence they were connected to these 3 murders.